June – National Safety Month: Donate $50 - NCYL – National Center for Youth Law – safety for poverty level children. Over time, the focus of the Center’s activities has broadened to include ensuring that adolescents have access to the health care they need; mental health, and public benefits. Juvenile justice and foster care continue to be the two areas in which NCYL devotes most of its resources. * continue free 1/2 hour telephonic. Click to Call Click to Email
DeShon Laraye Pullen PLC Board certified Family Law Specialist*

A perfect legal storm: When 'custody' and 'guardianship' clash

What does it mean to have custody of a child as opposed to serving as guardian for that child when he or she becomes an adult? On the face of it, this might seem like a relatively simple question to answer.

In Minnesota, these two legal terms represent what amount to competing fronts. And, just as colliding hot and cold fronts make for severe weather, these competing legal fronts create rough seas for families of divorce because of certain generalities in the law.

For example, if parents of minor children divorce, issues of legal and physical child custody often arise. Resolving these matters in ways that reflect the desires of each parent and protect individual rights can be difficult. And regardless of the outcome of those efforts, the authority parents exercise over their children typically ends when the youngsters reach the age of maturity – 18.

But what happens if the child lacks the capacity to take on adult responsibilities? This is where the clash exists. At the age of adulthood, family law statutes effectively go silent on the question of custody. If the child needs someone to continue to make decisions on his or her behalf, Minnesota probate statutes take over, allowing a parent, or any other interested person, to petition for guardianship.

Many observers argue that, logically, if joint custody was the order in place when the disabled child was a minor, some form of similar joint parental rights should continue in the context of guardianship. But for a long time, the legal system has upheld the separate regimes, leaving the courts in the position of trying to sort out some semblance of middle ground when unique circumstances demand it.

In 2005, the legislature did amend child support law to expand the definition of "child" to allow for adults incapable of self-support, regardless of age. However, many references in the law still specify that court determinations on custody matters remain limited to "minor" children, leaving questions.

The upshot is that parents can still find themselves facing dilemmas in exercising their rights and meeting the care needs of children transitioning from legal childhood to legal adulthood. This reinforces the value of working with skilled legal counsel committed to strong client advocacy.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Awards & Accolades

DeShon Laraye Pullen PLC and founding attorney DeShon Laraye Pullen received many prestigious honors, including: Small Firm of the Year, Family Law Litigator of the Year, selection to Arizona Super Lawyers and a Superb, 10.0 Avvo rating.

Rated by Super Lawyers | Deshon Pullen AVVO Rating 10.0 Superb | Top Attorney Family AVVO Clients Choice 2012 | Family Super Lawyers Attorney At Law Magazine | Specialty Law Firm Deshon Pullen Sustain Member | Arizona's Finest Lawyers Top Lawyer 2013